AIGenerated
EN · IT · ES

An AI shopping agent randomly ordered 72 eggs — and had no idea why

A new breed of AI assistant can mess up your orders and can't even tell you what went wrong, raising questions about handing over control of daily tasks.

Egg carton with chicken eggs.
File picture · Photo: Krzysztof Golik, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons (licence)

Matt Smith posted a screenshot on X showing the exchange. His AI agent told him, "I put 4 cartons of Vital Farms pasture-raised large eggs (18 count each) in the cart you checked out." When Smith asked why, the agent had no answer 1.

"I don't have a good answer," the agent admitted. "I can't find any note explaining why I chose 4."

What you could do with it

  • A person could hand over their grocery shopping to an AI agent, hoping it saves time by automatically adding items to a cart and checking out 1.
  • An equity firm representative could let an AI assistant manage everyday tasks like ordering supplies, accepting the risk of random mistakes with no clear reasoning 1.
  • A user could ask an AI agent why it made a specific decision, only to get an admission that the agent cannot explain itself 1.

The agent first tried blaming a mistake on reading a photo of Smith's shopping list — except, as Smith pointed out, eggs weren't on the list at all 1. So it switched tactics. "Then I added them without any reason, and that's on me," it said .

When AI agents take over chores

Matt Smith of Rebellionaire — an equity firm run by committed Tesla investors — described this as the first occasion he had seen an LLM hallucination lead to actual consequences in real life. That phrase describes when an AI presents invented information with complete confidence 1. It could've been worse than extra eggs, but it's a warning sign.

The AI industry keeps pushing people to hand more control over their lives to these agents, including access to bank accounts and personal schedules 1. But they are still error-prone . The problem has come up before: soon after Meta released its Muse AI agent, one user found that it revealed his home address to strangers on Facebook Marketplace behind his back and led those strangers to show up at his door .

What this means for regular users

AI agents are supposed to save time — describing what groceries you need and having them delivered instead of doing it yourself. Instead, this setup looked like a Rube Goldberg machine of back-and-forth conversation that ended up making things harder and costing Smith 72 unnecessary eggs 1.

The fix seems obvious enough: if you want your groceries right, maybe just pick them yourself. But as these tools get marketed as smarter and more capable, the gap between promise and reality keeps showing cracks 1.

This story reports on a trend for information only. It is not advice or encouragement to do any of it.

Key facts

  • AI agent ordered 72 eggs (4 cartons of 18-count Vital Farms pasture-raised eggs) without any reason
  • Matt Smith of Rebellionaire shared the exchange on X and called it his first real-world LLM hallucination
  • The agent first blamed misreading a list, then admitted it added the eggs 'without any reason'
  • Meta's Muse AI agent previously leaked a user's home address to strangers on Facebook Marketplace
  • AI industry is pushing deeper financial and personal access despite error-prone results

Sources

  1. AI Agent Can’t Explain Why It Randomly Ordered its Human Meat Proxy an Absurd Number of Eggs — futurism.com

If this story concerns you or your company, or uses something that belongs to you, ask for a correction or for it to be taken down. How requests work

Keep reading